Arguments For Life on Mars
NASA scientists first presented their argument for the presence of ancient life on Mars in a 1996 article in the journal, Science. Their main arguments are summarized below.
Tiny egg-shaped
or tubular features were found in Mars meteorite ALH84001. These features resemble many bacteria
on Earth and were thus interpreted as fossils of ancient Martian life. Most of the fossils are
between 20 and 100 nanometers in diameter, smaller than any normal bacteria on Earth. Recent
evidence, however, suggests that there do exist on Earth organisms of this size dubbed "nanobacteria".
There is still debate as to whether or not Earth nanobacteria have been proven to be life. If
nanobacteria are in fact living organisms, the finding of these features in ALH84001 is good evidence
for past life on Mars. For more information on nanobacteria, please see the
University of Queensland.
Carbonate is a type of rock formed from
liquid H2O (water) and CO2 (carbon dioxide) gas. Carbonate can be formed inorganically,
without the help of life. On Earth, however, life often helps in the formation of carbonate. The
carbonate found in the Martian meteorite ALH84001 was surrounded by microscopic features interpreted
as fossils by the scientists studying the meteorite. Though this finding in itself is inconclusive as
to the presence of life, it does indicate that liquid water was once present on Mars.
Magnetite is another type of rock found in meteorite ALH84001. The specific form of this rock found in the meteorite is chemically pure with no defects and is present in long, straight chains. On Earth, magnetite in this form found is only known to be produced by bacteria. It is reasonable to conclude, therefore, that this form of magnetite could only have been formed on Mars by Martian bacteria.
Complex molecules made of carbon (C) and hydrogen (H) forming many rings were found in ALH84001. These molecules, known as Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs), are created when living organisms decay. (They are also found in the dust between the stars - the interstellar medium (ISM) - where no life is known to exist.) Those PAHs found in the Martian meteorite are the same types of PAHs associated with the decay of life. (These specific PAHs are not necessarily in the same form as those created in the ISM.) In addition, the PAHs in ALH84001 were found near the carbonate, suggesting that the rock was indeed formed with the assistance of living organisms. The PAHs found in ALH84001 were not found in other, non-Martian meteorites found in the same location (Allyn Hills, Antarctica). This indicates that the PAHs found in ALH84001 were not formed through the decay of Earth organisms that found their way into the meteorite.
Recent evidence shows the Mars meteorite ALH84001 was never heated above 105 ° F (40 ° C). Life on Earth is known to survive temperatures of up to at least 120 ° F. Thus, though the original theory citing bacteria as the producer of various features in ALH84001 was not an equilibrium model, the presence of life in the rock is still a possibility. The temperature to form magnetite from iron-rich carbonate may or may not be less than 105 ° F, but the special form of the magnetite found in ALH84001 remains evidence in favor of ancient life on Mars.
The authors of the original paper announcing the possibility for life on ancient Mars admit that some of the features they interpreted as fossils were indeed formed inorganically. They continue that some other features could still have been made by life forms and that the possibility of life on Mars is still open.
The PAHs found in ALH84001 are unlike any found in Antarctic ice. They are also unlike those found in any other meteorites found in Antarctica. This is strong evidence that the PAHs in ALH84001 did not originate on Earth and must instead be of Martian origin.
Earth contamination has admittedly been found in the outer layers of the meteorite. This comes partly in the form of amino acids with carbon isotope ratios known to be of Earth descent. The decay of Antarctic life would leave behind PAHs when it decayed. Most of the PAHs that have been found in the meteorite are in the interior of the rock where no other forms of Earth contamination has been detected. As far as we are able to tell, the evidence for life in meteorite ALH84001 did not come from contamination by Earth life. As to whether or not these features are do to weathering on Earth cannot be proven either way.