Over the last few decades the Muslim world has faced a
dilemma. With boosted economies from oil profits and increased international
interest and investment, the cities of the Arabian Desert have been going
through a period of growth. This, in itself, is
not necessarily negative. However, with the booming economies have come
booming real estate markets, and
one of
the major issues in the Middle East today is how to reconcile the hundreds
of new structures with the traditional architecture of the Islamic
world. Garry Martin, in an article entitled "Building of the Middle
East Today-in Search of a Direction", identifies three ways that modern
Islamic architects approach this problem. The first is to ignore the past,
and focus on the most efficient Western styles available, as evidenced in
the hotel near the Holy Mosque in
Makkah to the left. This technique scars any
city of Islamic origin because it creates an alien environment and a feeling
of randomness within the cities. The second path Islamic architecture has
taken, which is the most common today, is to integrate the efficiency of
Western design while maintaining an Islamic exterior. This path has resulted
in high rises with traditional arches and domes seemingly "grafted"
onto their exteriors, such as the Hilton in Makkah below.
The final approach is to understand the essence of Islamic
architecture and to allow modern, Western architecture to be used as a tool
to implement structures conciliatory to those ideals and goals. "Architects
working today...have an opportunity to explore and transform the possibilities
of the machine age for the enrichment of architecture in the same way that
craftsmen explored the nature of geometrical and arabesque patterns."
This final solution seems extremely difficult to abide by but it basically
entails maintaining a semblance of regional identity and a relevance to
"the eternal principals of Islam" as Islamic architecture has
traditionally done.