faculty     students     alumni     courses     major/minor requirements      internships     study abroad     newsletters/journals


Home
Advising

Assessment
CERF
EcoHouse
Environmental Audits
Environmental Groups
EnviroThursday
Graduate Programs
Honors Thesis
In the News
Katharine Ordway Natural
    History Study Area

Related Links
Scholarships
Student Projects
Sustainability Office
Talloires Declaration
Presidents Climate
    Commitment

Three Rivers Center

 

Environmental Studies Department
Olin Rice 249
1600 Grand Avenue
St. Paul, MN 55105
651-696-6274
Comments & questions to:
esson@macalester.edu

Campus Paper Waste Reduction Project

By Heather Crawford and Kelly Forney
May 2000


The piles of abandoned paper that accumulate beside the printers in the Library and Humanities computers labs, the recyclable paper found in trash bins and the large volumes of one-sided reading material printed for classes are all testament to the rampant careless use of paper on campus. Our goals in this project were to reduce paper use on campus as well as increase reuse and recycling of used paper.

Current Paper Use:

In conversations with Jim Jeffers, Head of Purchasing and Central Stores, we attempted to determine how much paper is being used by the campus. Jeffers oversees ordering paper for all of the academic departments, the library, Computing Information Technology (CIT) and the administrative offices. All paper used on campus, with the exception of those jobs handled by document services and the copy rooms managed by Document Services, is ordered through the purchasing office.

At the current time, Purchasing does not have the staff necessary to track paper use on campus beyond the amount ordered; it is distributed to departments upon request but this distribution is not recorded by Central Stores. According to Jeffers, the biggest paper uses are Admissions, Alumni and Development, the academic departments and the library. There are 5,000 sheets per carton of paper and 40 cartons per pallet. Macalester College orders approximately one pallet of paper per month. The library alone orders about 15 cartons from Central Stores every two weeks when it is busy.

According to statistics from the Macalester Recycling Office (MacRO), the amount of paper recycled on campus (newspaper, mixed paper and books) for the year June 1997 to June 1998 totaled 117,095 pounds. This amount increased to 151,870 pounds in the year ending June 1999. It is unclear whether this trend is the result of a greater percentage of used paper being recycled or if paper use has simply increased.

Current Paper Purchased:

Our current paper contract is for Springhill Recycled Relay paper from International Paper. This paper is 30% total recovered fibers (scraps from the production of other paper at the mill) and 30% post-consumer fiber. Our local vendor is Unisource and Macalester College pays $5.37 per thousand sheets. Jim Jeffers has contacted Unisource to get additional information on our paper, including whether or not chlorine is used in the production process and whether or not the other 40% of the fibers is harvested from old-growth forests.

We are under contract with Springhill for another 18 months (as of April 2000). At the end of this contract, bids will be accepted for a new contract and this would be the first opportunity to change the type of paper purchased by the college.

We wanted to find an alternative type of paper to propose to Jeffers, so we looked at what papers other schools were using that had already researched the recycled paper issue. The name that came up most often was Eureka 100% Recycled PCF (Produced Chlorine-Free) paper. Additional information about this paper is available at: http://www.greenculture.com/pr/paper_e.html

The information was given to Jeffers who said that he would look into any 100% recycled papers that we found for him. The one stipulation is that they must be of the right quality for use in laser printers.

Document Services:

In the past, other groups investigating the issue of paper use were unable to get information from Document Services on the number of copies and amount of paper that the campus orders through them. They are a private contractor and it is unclear how much we will be able to work with them to change paper use on campus.

In addition to jobs that are ordered and processed through their office in the Lampert Building, they also manage the copy rooms in the academic buildings. Here departments can make their own copies and have their services charged to their individual accounts. Paper is distributed to these rooms on a weekly basis, but the use is not tracked. The copy rooms are left unlocked and anyone can walk in and take reams for personal use or office use. In addition, the copiers only keep track of the number of copies made, and do not distinguish between single and double-sided copies, therefore it is not possible to know how much paper is being used. See "Future Action" for additional information.

Problems:

In order to come up with solutions to the problem of overuse of paper on campus, we first needed to identify the problems associated with it.

  • Because electronic reserves take a long time to print (sometimes up to ten minutes), print jobs may be repeatedly sent or just abandoned. A large volume of paper is wasted in this way.
  • Pages printed from the Internet sometimes come out with most information missing.
  • Duplex printing or photocopying is not currently possible from all machines on campus.
  • Many students are unaware of the option of duplex printing and photocopying or do not know how to use it.
  • Most faculty members do not encourage students to turn in assignments on paper that is printed on both sides. A large volume of the material printed for students is not double-sided.
  • Paper waste can still be seen in regular trash bins despite the presence of recycling containers.
  • Students do not realize the cost of their paper consumption habits.

Raising Awareness:

To raise awareness of the issue on campus, we did several things to educate people on over-consumption of paper and ways that they could change their consumption habits.

  • Wrote an opinion column for The Mac Weekly raising the issue, presenting the current situation and asking people to take steps to conserve paper.
  • Submitted notice to The Bulletin asking professors to announce in class that they will accept papers printed double-sided or on paper that has already been printed on one side.
  • Ran announcements in the Today about where paper can be recycled, printing double-sided and the number of resources saved by recycling paper.
  • Posted new signs for paper recycling bins, one-sided paper boxes and duplex/manual feed printing options in the library and computer labs.

Future Action:

Possible avenues for future work include, but are not limited to:

Document Services:

  • Making double-sided printing standard, requiring departments to check "single-sided" if they do not want documents to be printed double-sided. Currently a box must be checked on the order form if double-sided copies are desired.
  • Exploring alternative paper options; it is unclear how feasible this is considering that they are only one division of an independent contracting company.

Associated Colleges of the Twin Cities (ACTC):

Work with other campuses, gathering information on their paper use, their approaches to reducing paper consumption, etc. The St. Thomas student paper printed an article in spring 2000 about the issue of paper use on their campus, in which they consider charging students for printing, etc. This may be a point of collaboration between campuses.

CIT:

  • Duplex printing should be made available from all machines on campus. This means that a) each printer should have a duplex-printing unit installed (which can be added later); b) there must be a network connection between the computer and duplex printer; and c) the printer driver software must be on the computer.
  • A proposal has been made to implement a system to hold students accountable for the amount of paper they print on. This might involve allowing a quota per student, which if surpassed, will cause charges to be incurred to the student. The limit would be set such that only squanderers would go over. On all printers there would be a scanner for ID codes. Another way this might be implemented is installing a software counting device in all computers which counts the number of pages printed once a person has logged on. This tally would automatically be sent to the cashier’s office. The network upgrades necessary to implement this system are already scheduled.
  • A different version of Netscape, 4.0, should be put on the Novell network since it prints with fewer problems.

Purchasing:

When printers and photocopiers are bought in the future, they should already have the duplex system built into the machine.

MacRO:

Although there are many restrictions on the placing of recycling bins around campus, e.g. space limits, fire marshal codes and aesthetic issues, there is still room to improve the recycling program at Macalester. There is a new labeling project in process which aims to have every bin on campus, including regular trash bins, uniformly labeled. Also, Dupre residence hall has just been furnished with new recycling bins. There are plans to re-bin other campus buildings after remodeling takes place.

Education:

Further education on ways to cut down on paper use and why to do so is still needed for students and faculty alike. For example a print job should never be sent more than once unless the person has checked with the lab consultant to make sure that it did not already go through. Hopefully this information, as well as information on duplex printing and photocopying, will be part of next year’s new student library orientation. A survey of students’ paper use habits was recently completed by Heather Crawford, Joel Creswell and MG Eisenhart, the results of which will offer further insight into the issue.

    


Macalester College · 1600 Grand Avenue, St. Paul, MN 55105  USA · 651-696-6000
Comments and questions to esson@macalester.edu