In January of 2007, the Indianapolis Colts pulled off the largest comeback in NFL conference championship game history. Complete with trick plays and on-field fireworks provided by quarterback Peyton Manning, the team would rally from a 21-3 deficit to beat the New England Patriots, 38-34. Dan Emerson ’76 was there with his wife and daughters and watched the thrilling evening unfold. “It was truly epic,” he says. To this day, it remains his favorite moment in more than four decades with the team.
In a dedicated run that began in 1984, Emerson started working for the Colts before they even officially arrived in Indianapolis. As a senior associate at an Indianapolis law firm hired to defend the team from an eminent domain proceeding filed by its previous host city, Baltimore, Emerson developed the legal theory that helped secure the team’s move to Indiana. His first case successful, he never really left the Colts, eventually joining the team full-time, rising to general counsel and then chief legal officer.
While working with longtime owner and friend Jim Irsay, who died in 2025, and now a new generation of Irsay family ownership, Emerson has advised the team on everything from the contracts of Manning and Andrew Luck to the construction of Lucas Oil Stadium. Now, as he prepares to retire after forty-two years with the Colts, Emerson reflects on failure, preparation, and the importance of having fun.
Never let yourself be outprepared
I got some really good advice from senior lawyers when I was a brand-new attorney: Never let yourself be outprepared or outworked by the other side. And that “other side” isn’t necessarily an adversary—it’s anyone that you’re dealing with. You always want to be as prepared as you possibly can. Failure to prepare is preparing to fail. That’s such easy advice, but I took it to heart, and it’s served me well.
You learn more from losing than winning
Before I was spending all my time with the Colts, I was an employment litigator and a commercial litigator. There, you often lose motions, arguments, and entire cases. Every time you lose something, you’ve got to assign a reason to it—work to understand why it happened and learn from the experience. You learn a lot more from losing than you do from winning. Every time a motion I made would fail or a judge wouldn’t rule my way on something, I always did everything I could to learn from it. That way you minimize the likelihood of it happening again.

Lead by example
Leaders should always lead by example. You want to maintain your credibility, be straight with people, and work your tail off so others can see that’s the way to do it. I also try to inject a fair amount of humor and humility into what I do—and I’ve found that works for me. There are plenty of people out there in leadership positions who often don’t lead by example and, honestly, are kind of jerks, and I think that hurts their ability to be effective.
Build relationships away from the office
Many of my strongest professional relationships were formed outside the courtroom and away from Colts headquarters. Instead, they came from a softball league put on by the Indianapolis Bar Association. It gave me the opportunity to meet all sorts of other lawyers from other firms on a neutral field. If you develop a relationship with your potential adversary on neutral turf, it helps the relationship, and you create a basis for trust in your work. And I’ve found it’s usually easier making friends with a bat in your hand than a cocktail.
Stay in a job only if you’re having fun
The older I get, the more I value fun. I’ve known a lot of people who have stayed in jobs for years, even though they’re not really enjoying themselves. That’s not worth it, and it’s corrosive. Do everything you can to be kind and have fun while you’re on the clock, and make sure you can look at yourself in the mirror at the end of the day and admit whether you really are enjoying your work, day in and day out. It sounds like something off a greeting card. But damn it, it’s true.




