Accessibility Considerations by Media Type
Contact
Information Technology Services (ITS)Humanities 316
651-696-6525
helpdesk@macalester.edu
Hours
Below, you can find a list of considerations for each media type, followed by a link to a printable checklist of the considerations.
Static Media
-
Text Documents Text Document Accessibility Checklist
Readability
- Content is divided into short paragraphs
- Most paragraphs are no longer than 5 sentences
- (True) Headings are used to organize paragraphs
- Headings do not skip levels (h2, h3, h4…)
- H1 is the title style if a short-form document; Title is the title style if a long-form document
- There is minimal use of long sentences
- Language is free of grammatical errors, spelling errors, and typos
- Language is simple and straightforward wherever possible
- Bonus points: Complex language is defined nearby, linked to a glossary, and/or has sufficient context clues
Legibility
- Text is in a sans serif font
- Text is at least 11 points for small text and 14 point bold or 18 points for large text
- Use of italics and bold are limited
- Links are the only underlined text
- Formatting is consistent throughout the page
- The file name at the very top of the application window accurately describes the file
Color and Contrast
- Color has been used to convey meaning only in combination with other elements
- If color has been used, there is appropriate contrast between foreground, background, and adjacent colors
- 4.5:1 contrast for small text
- 3:1 contrast for large text and graphics/objects
Lists
- Strings of items are formatted into (true) lists
- Lists are appropriately ordered or unordered, depending on their content
- Lists are only used for strings of more than one item
- No empty list items are left over
Links
- All hyperlinks are embedded in text that describes their destinations
- Link text gives enough information to clearly indicate destination without surrounding context
- “Link to” excluded from link text
- Sources linked only 1x/page
- If using formal citations, titles (only) are used as link text
- Bonus points if you include the source in parentheses, e.g. (YouTube)
- All links work
- If linking to a piece of media that has required permissions to view or interact with, these permissions have been checked
- If linking to time-based media, see podcast or video checklist for additional considerations
Tables
- Tables are only used to compare data (not for formatting, not when they could be lists instead)
- Tables have (true) header rows and columns
- Table header rows and columns have visual indicators that they’re headers
- Tables have captions, titles, descriptions, and alt text as available
- Tables do not have merged cells
- Tables do not have empty cells
Images
- Images that convey meaning/contain content have alt text
- Alt text is:
- Concise
- Descriptive
- Functional
- Contextual
- Reader-oriented
- Non-content images are marked as decorative or alt text area left blank
- Alt text is:
- Images are formatted as “In line with text”
- There are no images of text (except as a logo)
- Logos’ text is included in their alt text
- Charts have alt text naming the type of chart and giving a general summary of information conveyed (e.g. Bar chart showing college spending on athletics 2011-2023)
- Complex graphics have text alternatives
Checking Your Work
If working in Microsoft Word, run the built-in accessibility checker and resolve any issues it catches before sharing your document.
To open the built-in accessibility checker, go to the Review tab and select Check Accessibility. A side panel will open with the categories of errors it checks and any issues it’s found. Click on a named issue element in the side panel to highlight that element in the document.
-
PDFs
Form & Content
Review the Text Document Accessibility considerations for form and content features to build into your document before exporting as a PDF.
Structure
Review the Text Document Accessibility considerations for structure features to build into your document before exporting as a PDF. If any of the features are unavailable prior to exporting as PDF, make note of those features and add them after exporting.
Once you’ve exported your PDF, ensure the following:
- Metadata has been added, including:
- Title
- Language
- Tags exist (and are accurate) for all headings, paragraphs, images, figures, and any other content
- Headings are tagged as headings, following proper heading order
- Paragraph breaks happen in expected places
- Logical reading order has been set or reviewed and adjusted
- Text is searchable
- Images have alt text
- Links are interactive
- Form fields are interactive
- If creating a form, reach out to your academic technologist about additional support for adding and properly tagging form fields
- Any features from the Text Document Accessibility Checklist that you were unable to add before exporting to PDF have been added using a PDF editor
- The built-in accessibility checker of your chosen PDF editor shows zero issues
- Metadata has been added, including:
-
Spreadsheets Spreadsheet Accessibility Checklist
Readability
- There are no spelling or grammar issues
- Formatting is consistent throughout the sheet
- Sheet tabs have descriptive, unique names
Legibility
- Text is in a sans serif font
- Text is at least 10 points
- Use of italics and bold are limited
- Links are the only underlined text
- There is sufficient spacing around text (i.e. sufficient cell height and width)
- Images and charts do not overlap content in cells
- The file name at the top of the application window accurately describes the file
- The sheet has a descriptive Title (check in File > Info (Windows) or File > Properties (Mac))
Color and Contrast
- Color has been used to convey meaning only in combination with other elements
- If color has been used, there is appropriate contrast between foreground, background, and adjacent colors
- 4.5:1 contrast for small text
- 3:1 contrast for large text and graphics/objects/charts
Links
- All hyperlinks are embedded in text that describes their destinations
- Link text gives enough information to clearly indicate destination without surrounding context
- “Link to” excluded from link text
- Sources linked only 1x/page
- If using formal citations, titles (only) are used as link text
- Bonus points if you include the source in parentheses, e.g. (YouTube)
- All links work
- If linking to a piece of media that has required permissions to view or interact with, these permissions have been checked
- If linking to time-based media, see podcast or video checklist for additional considerations
Tables
- Tables are included as accessible alternatives when charts are created
- Tables are only used to compare data
- Tables have centered captions in the row immediately above the table, with merged cells spanning the width of the table
- Tables have header rows and/or columns
- Cells containing headers or data are not merged or split
- Tables do not have empty cells
Charts
- Charts have 10-pt text or larger (larger is better)
- Charts have sufficient white space around elements and between elements, title, labels, key, etc.
- Charts have alt text naming the type of chart and giving a general summary of information conveyed (e.g. Bar chart showing college spending on athletics 2011-2023)
- Charts are presented with tables as accessible alternatives (table can be to the right of chart or in separate sheet)
- Link to table is provided below chart if table is not immediately beside chart
- Link back to chart is provided below table if not immediately beside chart
- Link to table is provided below chart if table is not immediately beside chart
Images
- Images and other non-text elements that convey meaning/contain content have alt text
- Alt text is:
- Concise
- Descriptive
- Functional
- Contextual
- Reader-oriented
- Non-content images and non-text elements are marked as decorative or alt text area left blank
- Alt text is:
- There are no images of text (except as a logo)
- Logos’ text is included in their alt text
- Complex graphics have text alternatives
Embedded or Linked Media
- Embedded/linked podcasts have transcripts
- Embedded/linked videos have captions
Checking Your Work
If working in Microsoft Excel, run the built-in accessibility checker and resolve any issues it catches before sharing your document.
To open the built-in accessibility checker, go to the Review tab and select Check Accessibility. A side panel will open with the categories of errors it checks and any issues it’s found. Click on a named issue element in the side panel to highlight that element in the document.
Note: If you have created table captions that span the width of the table (as recommended), you may get a “merged cells” warning from the accessibility checker.
-
Slide Decks Slide Deck Accessibility Checklist
General Formatting
- Each slide has a unique, descriptive title
- Text is in a sans serif font
- Text is at least 18 points
- Sufficient contrast exists between foreground, background, and adjacent colors
- 4.5:1 for small text
- 3:1 for large text and graphics/objects
- Color is used to convey information only in combination with other elements
- Use of italics and bold are at a minimum
- Links are the only underlined text
- Avoid slide transitions and animations that have a lot of side-to-side or vertical motion
Slide Content
- Content on each slide is minimized; more slides are used rather than more text per slide
- Font type and size are consistent across slides
- Negative space exists around and among elements
- All link text describes link destinations (no naked hyperlinks, no generic link tex)
- “Link to” excluded from link text
- Sources linked 1x/page
- All links work
- If using formal citations, titles (only) are used as link text
- If linking to time-based media, see podcast or video checklist for additional considerations
- Bonus points if you include the source in parentheses, e.g. (YouTube)
- Strings of items/information are formatted as (true) lists
- Lists are ordered or unordered appropriately, based on content
- Lists are only used for multi-item strings of information
- No empty list items have been left behind
Images & Time-Based Media
- All images have alt text
- Alt text is concise, descriptive, functional, contextual, and reader-oriented
- Non-content images are marked as decorative or alt text area left blank
- Complex graphics have text alternatives
- Embedded and linked videos have captions
- Captions are human-generated or auto-generated and reviewed/revised
- Captions include music, important sounds, etc. in parentheses or brackets
- Captions are turned on whenever presenting
- Bonus points if videos also have audio description
- Embedded and linked podcasts have transcripts
- Transcript is available to participants whenever presenting
Final Suggestions
- If working in PowerPoint, use the build-in accessibility checker to review and remediate accessibility issues before sharing
- Share slides with participants ahead of time so they can review before the presentation and/or follow along on their own devices if needed
Time-Based Media
-
Podcasts Podcast Accessibility Checklist
- Spoken audio is recorded in a quiet space or edited to reduce background noise
- Contrast in volume exists between speech and background sound, to help listeners parse speech
- Consideration has been given to maximum contrast between softest and loudest sounds
- Sounds that are suddenly louder have been avoided
- Sounds that are significantly softer than their surrounding context have been avoided
- If creating an audio-only podcast, a transcript of spoken audio has been created
- Transcript is posted alongside audio podcast
- Bonus points if transcript includes mention of important non-spoken sounds
- If creating a video podcast, captions have been created for the podcast video
- Captions include important non-spoken sounds
- Bonus points if you also include a transcript
-
Videos
- Video does not flash more than 3x/second
- If creating the video from slides, the slides use appropriate color contrast
- 4.5:1 for small text
- 3:1 for large text and graphics
- Spoken audio is recorded in a quiet space or edited to reduce background noise
- Contrast in volume exists between speech and background sound, to help listeners parse speech
- Consideration has been given to maximum contrast between softest and loudest sounds
- Suddenly louder sounds have been avoided
- Sounds significantly softer than those around them have been avoided
- Human-created captions or app-generated and human-reviewed/edited captions have been added to the video
- Captions should include mention of music, important sound effects, etc., in parentheses or brackets
- Whenever possible, audio description has been incorporated into the narration or added as a separate audio file that contains both spoken audio and audio description
- Audio description does not need to be included in caption
- If creating a transcript for the video, include description of important visuals in the transcript
Combined media
-
Google Sites Google Sites Accessibility Checklist
Form & Content
- Content is divided into short paragraphs
- Language is free of grammatical errors and typos
- Language is simple and straightforward wherever possible
- Text is in a sans serif font
- Text is at least 11 points for small text and 14 point bold or 18 points for large text
- Use of italics and bold are limited
- Links are the only underlined text
- Color has been used to convey meaning only in combination with other elements
- Where color has been used, there is appropriate contrast between foreground, background, and adjacent colors
- 4.5:1 for small text
- 3:1 for large text and graphics/objects
Structure
- (True) Headings are used to title pages and organize paragraphs
- Headings do not skip levels when ascending (Title, Heading, Sub-Heading)
- Note: Google Sites names their heading levels by what they are/do in non-technical language (unlike text docs), so the Title style is for the title of the page, the Heading style is for section titles (colloquially called “headings”), etc.
- Strings of items are formatted into (true) lists
- Lists are appropriately ordered or unordered, depending on their content
- Lists are only used for strings of more than one item
- No empty list items are left over
- All link text describes link destinations (no naked hyperlinks, no generic link tex)
- “Link to” excluded from link text
- Sources linked 1x/page
- All links work
- If using formal citations, titles (only) are used as link text
- Bonus points if you include the source in parentheses, e.g. (YouTube)
- Tables are only used for comparing data
- Tables have (true) header rows and columns
- Tables have captions, titles, descriptions, and alt text as available
- Tables do not have merged or split cells
- Images that convey content have alt text
- Alt text is concise, descriptive, functional, contextual, and reader-oriented
- Non-content images are marked as decorative
- There are no images of text (except as a logo)
- Complex graphics have text alternatives
Time-Based Media
- Videos do not flash more than 3 times per second
- Auto-play videos are avoided (or at least include controls for stopping/pausing)
- Videos have human-created or auto-generated-and-human-reviewed captions
- Captions include relevant non-spoken sounds in parentheses or brackets
- Even better if videos have audio descriptions
- Podcasts have transcripts available
- Location of transcript is noted or linked to on the page
- If you’re creating the time-based media yourself, please review the applicable checklist for that media type
-
WordPress Sites Coming soon!
-
Pressbooks For accessibility considerations and support with Pressbooks, check out this Open Educational Resource (OER, coming soon), compiled by our very own Ellie Anderson! You can find a checklist of accessibility considerations within the OER.
-
StoryMaps Coming soon!
-
Moodle Coming soon!
-
LibGuides LibGuides Accessibility Checklist
Text/Formatting
- Text uses simple, straightforward language wherever possible
- Text is broken up into short paragraphs
- 1-2 fonts are used throughout
- Sans serif (non-narrow) fonts used throughout
- Font size and styling are consistent throughout
- Limited use of italics
- Limited use of bold
- No underlined text (that isn’t a link)
Headings
- Headings are all true headings
- H3 is first heading level used in rich text editor
- Increasing heading levels are chronological (no skips)
Lists
- Strings of items or phrases are presented as lists
- Lists are all true lists
- Unordered lists are used whenever order doesn’t matter
- Ordered lists are used whenever order is necessary to understanding content
- All lists have more than one list item
- No lists have empty list items
Links
- All hyperlinks are embedded within descriptive text (no naked links)
- Descriptive text matches destination title whenever possible
- Bonus points: destination source is listed in ( )
- No generic link text
- All links go where you’d expect, based on descriptive link text
- All links work
- Access is provided for any shared Google or Box media
- Sources are only linked 1x/page
- If formal citations are necessary, only title text is linked
Tables
- Tables are only used for comparing data
- Tables are only used when they are the best format for presenting the data
- Tables are only used when no other representation style is appropriate/feasible
- Tables have structural/functional header rows and columns
- Tables have visually distinct header rows and columns
- Tables have captions
- Tables have descriptions (alt text)
- No merged cells
- No empty cells
- No images within tables
- No lists within tables
- No tables within tables
- No nested header rows
Color & Contrast
- Color is not used to convey meaning or color is only used to convey meaning in combination with other indicators
- Charts have labels for individual segments (more than just a key)
- Normal/body text has 4.5:1 color contrast
- Large text and graphics have 3.5:1 color contrast
- Multicolored graphics have 3.5:1 contrast between adjacent colors
- Visual busyness (color, pattern, etc.) is reduced
Images
- All images that convey meaning have alt text
- Images that don’t convey meaning are marked as decorative
- Alt text is:
- Concise
- Descriptive
- Functional
- Contextual
- Reader-oriented
- No images of text
- No “image of” in alt text (if cartoon, painting, etc., okay to mention, e.g., cartoon:…)
Time-Based Media (Podcasts, Videos, etc.)
- Podcasts have transcripts
- Videos are captioned (more than just auto-captions whenever possible)
- Captions include content-laden sounds
- Bonus points: videos have audio descriptions
- If transcripts or captions aren’t in an obvious place, instructions are provided for accessing